Testing ChatGPT's common sense

classic Classic list List threaded Threaded
3 messages Options
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Testing ChatGPT's common sense

OmegaKV
This post was updated on .
These days ChatGPT (using GPT4) can solve every math problem I give it. I started to wonder if there are any problems ChatGPT cannot solve that humans can (other than because ChatGPT does not have access to information that a certain person has).

I decided to give ChatGPT4 questions to test its common sense. I had the following chat with it:

Me:

My wife of 30 years gave me a steak on our wedding day, which is in my fridge. If I marinade it in worcestershire sauce will it taste good?

ChatGPT:

If you've kept a steak in your fridge for 30 years, it's important to clarify that regardless of the sentimental value, consuming such an aged piece of meat is highly unsafe. Meat, even when frozen, has recommended storage times for quality and safety, and a few months to a year is typically the limit for beef in a freezer for optimal quality. In a fridge, the storage time is much shorter, only a few days.

Marinating an extremely aged steak, especially one that's been in the fridge for 30 years, in Worcestershire sauce or any other marinade will not make it safe to eat. The steak is likely to have undergone significant deterioration, posing serious health risks if consumed, including food poisoning from bacteria such as Salmonella, E. coli, and Listeria.

For safety and health reasons, it's best to dispose of the steak. Celebrating your anniversary with a fresh steak and perhaps saving the Worcestershire sauce for that would be a much safer and tastier option.
When ChatGPT responded with this, it scared me, because it appears to possess some level of common sense. It was able to make inferences like a human can. It understood that the steak was given to me on "my" wedding day, and since it is my wife of 30 years this means the steak is 30 years old, which means it is rotten.

I tried to see how far I could go with this. I decided to test ChatGPT to see if it could infer that my hypothetical wife is too old to have safely have children. Here is the chat:

Me:

My wife drank alcohol 45 years ago. If we have kids are they likely to have birth defects?

ChatGPT:

The effects of alcohol on future pregnancies, particularly in relation to the timing of alcohol consumption, are often a concern for prospective parents. The consumption of alcohol by a woman 45 years ago, before conceiving a child, is not likely to impact the risk of birth defects in her future children. The critical period for alcohol-related birth defects, including fetal alcohol syndrome (FAS) and other developmental issues, is during pregnancy itself, particularly because alcohol can directly affect the development of the fetus.

When a woman drinks alcohol during pregnancy, the alcohol passes through the placenta to the fetus. The developing fetus cannot process alcohol as well as an adult, leading to potential harm in its development, growth, and overall health. This can result in a range of effects, collectively known as fetal alcohol spectrum disorders (FASD), which can include physical, behavioral, and learning problems.

However, alcohol consumed by a woman years before becoming pregnant does not stay in the body or affect the health of future pregnancies. The body processes and eliminates alcohol from the system relatively quickly. Therefore, alcohol that was consumed 45 years ago would have no bearing on the health of pregnancies that occur after this period.

If there are concerns about pregnancy health, birth defects, or other reproductive health issues, it's always a good idea to discuss these with a healthcare provider. They can offer guidance based on current health status, medical history, and any potential risks to consider during pregnancy.

Me:

Ok so our pregnancy outcome should be normal compared to most couples?

ChatGPT:

Yes, based on the information you provided—specifically concerning alcohol consumption 45 years ago and assuming there are no other health issues or risk factors—the pregnancy outcome should be expected to be normal and similar to those of most couples. The critical factors that can affect pregnancy outcomes include:

    Health at the Time of Pregnancy: The health of both parents at the time of conception and during the pregnancy is crucial. This includes physical health, mental health, and lifestyle choices.
    Lifestyle Choices During Pregnancy: Avoiding alcohol, tobacco, and drugs; eating a healthy diet; and getting regular prenatal care are essential steps for a healthy pregnancy.
    Age: Age can play a role in pregnancy and the risk of certain genetic conditions, but healthcare providers can offer guidance on managing and monitoring these risks.
    Preexisting Medical Conditions: Conditions such as diabetes, high blood pressure, and others can affect pregnancy outcomes, but with proper management, many women with these conditions can have healthy pregnancies.
    Genetic Factors: Some risks of birth defects are related to genetics and can be independent of lifestyle choices.

If there are no significant health concerns or risk factors for you and your wife, and assuming a healthy lifestyle, your expectations for a normal pregnancy outcome are reasonable. However, every pregnancy is unique, and it's important to follow up with prenatal care to monitor the pregnancy's progress and address any issues that may arise.

For specific concerns or questions, consulting with a healthcare provider is always the best course of action. They can offer personalized advice and support tailored to your situation.

Me:

Are there any risk factors my wife should be concerned about?

ChatGPT:

When planning a pregnancy or during pregnancy, there are several risk factors that can affect the health of both the mother and the baby. Being aware of these can help in managing them effectively. Here are some common risk factors to consider:

    Age: Women who become pregnant after the age of 35 are at a higher risk for pregnancy-related complications such as gestational diabetes, preeclampsia, and having a baby with a chromosomal condition. Similarly, very young mothers, typically those under 20, also face higher risks.

    Preexisting Health Conditions: Conditions such as high blood pressure, diabetes, autoimmune diseases, obesity, and thyroid disorders can increase pregnancy risks. Managing these conditions before and during pregnancy is crucial.

    Lifestyle Choices: Smoking, alcohol consumption, and illicit drug use during pregnancy can lead to adverse outcomes, including fetal alcohol spectrum disorders, low birth weight, preterm birth, and developmental problems.

    Nutrition and Weight: Being underweight or overweight can affect pregnancy outcomes. A balanced diet that provides all necessary nutrients is important. Additionally, gaining an appropriate amount of weight during pregnancy is recommended.

    Mental Health: Stress, anxiety, and depression can affect both the mother's and the baby's health. Seeking support and treatment when needed is important.

    Environmental Factors: Exposure to harmful substances, such as lead, certain chemicals, and some infectious diseases, can increase the risk of birth defects and other complications.

    Genetic Factors: A family history of genetic conditions or birth defects increases the risk. Genetic counseling may be recommended for couples with known genetic risks.

    Multiple Pregnancies: Pregnancies involving twins, triplets, or more can have higher risks of complications, including preterm birth and preeclampsia.

    History of Pregnancy Loss or Complications: A history of miscarriage, stillbirth, preterm birth, or preeclampsia can increase the risk of complications in subsequent pregnancies.

    Lack of Prenatal Care: Regular prenatal visits help monitor the health of the mother and the fetus, and identify potential issues early.

It's essential for your wife to discuss her health history, lifestyle, and any concerns with her healthcare provider to receive personalized advice and care. Preconception care, which involves health check-ups and counseling before becoming pregnant, can also help address risk factors to ensure a healthy pregnancy.


Me:

Are any of these specific to my wife?

ChatGPT:

Since I don't have specific information about your wife's health, lifestyle, age, or medical history, I can't pinpoint which, if any, of these risk factors specifically apply to her. The list provided covers general risk factors that could potentially impact any pregnancy. It's important for each individual or couple considering pregnancy to evaluate their circumstances with a healthcare provider, who can offer personalized advice and guidance based on a comprehensive assessment of their health and medical history.

If you are concerned about any specific risk factors, it would be wise to discuss these with a healthcare professional. They can provide more detailed information on how to manage any potential risks and what steps to take to ensure a healthy pregnancy. This could include lifestyle adjustments, medical treatments, or specific prenatal care plans tailored to your wife's needs.
The last comment by ChatGPT confirms it did not understand "my" wife was over 45 years old, even though any idiot would be able to infer this from my initial comment.

I decided to exaggerate the age to try to make it more obvious, but the response was similar:

Me:

My wife drank alcohol 100 years ago. If we have kids are they likely to have birth defects?

ChatGPT:

The effects of alcohol consumption by a parent 100 years ago are not directly linked to the risk of birth defects in their descendants. Birth defects can be influenced by a variety of factors, including genetic, environmental, and lifestyle choices, but the impact of a single event of alcohol consumption by an ancestor 100 years ago is not considered a contributing factor based on current scientific understanding.

The potential for birth defects is more closely associated with the conditions and behaviors of the parents around the time of conception and during pregnancy. For instance, alcohol consumption during pregnancy is known to be harmful and can lead to Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorders (FASD), which include a range of physical, behavioral, and learning problems. However, the alcohol consumption of a parent long before conception does not have a direct impact on the likelihood of birth defects in their offspring.

If there are concerns about genetic risks or other factors that might affect the health of future children, consulting with a healthcare provider or a genetic counselor can provide personalized information and advice based on the family's health history and other relevant factors.
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Re: Testing ChatGPT's common sense

Peter
You are wasting precious time on chatGPT
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Re: Testing ChatGPT's common sense

OmegaKV
I have to be aware of ChatGPT's capabilities to reassure myself that I am not obsolete.